Emily Finn Death and Obituary – Emily Finn, an 18-year-old recent high school graduate from West Sayville, New York, tragically lost her life on Wednesday, November 26, 2025, in a shocking act of violence that has shaken the local community. The incident, classified as a murder-suicide attempt, occurred at the home of her 17-year-old ex-boyfriend on Shenandoah Boulevard in Nesconset.
Incident Details
According to authorities, Emily Finn had gone to her ex-boyfriend’s residence to return his personal belongings following a breakup conducted over the phone. At approximately 11:10 a.m., the situation escalated when the teen allegedly shot Finn with a shotgun. Following the attack, the suspect turned the weapon on himself, shooting himself in the face. Emergency responders were alerted by the suspect’s parents, who were outside the home during the shooting.
Emily Finn was pronounced dead at the scene. The 17-year-old suspect survived his self-inflicted gunshot wound and was immediately transported to Stony Brook University Hospital, where he remained in critical but stable condition. Law enforcement confirmed that the teen would face charges of second-degree murder and is expected to be arraigned once his medical condition permits.
Victim Background
Emily Finn was a promising young student, recently graduating from Sayville High School. She had just begun her freshman year at SUNY Oneonta and was described by friends and family as bright, compassionate, and full of potential. Her sudden and violent death has left family, classmates, and the broader community in deep mourning.
Suspect and Motive
While police noted that there was no prior history of domestic violence between the two teens, a family friend suggested that the breakup—described as “puppy love”—had a profound impact on the 17-year-old suspect. Investigators are still examining the circumstances leading up to the incident to better understand the motive.
Community Response
The tragedy has prompted an outpouring of grief and support from local residents, classmates, and officials. Counseling services and community support networks have been made available for those affected, including friends and family of Emily Finn.
Authorities continue to investigate the incident and are expected to release additional details as the legal process unfolds. The case underscores the critical importance of addressing teen mental health, the warning signs of emotional distress, and the devastating consequences of interpersonal violence.